Front-Surface vs Second-Surface Mirrors: What Changes in the Image
By Rocco (Roi) Ramon - licensed architect, founder of Studio Yabaye
A household mirror and a front-surface mirror use the same two materials: a sheet of glass and a thin layer of metal. The difference is which side of the glass the metal is on. In a kaleidoscope, where the image is built from many reflections laid edge to edge, it decides whether the joints between sectors are sharp or doubled.
This article compares the two mirror types and shows how to tell which one an instrument uses.
What a mirror is made of
A metal such as aluminium or silver reflects most of the visible light that reaches it. Glass transmits most of it and reflects a small share. A mirror is therefore a metal film on a flat, rigid carrier, and glass is the carrier. The film can be put on either face:
Second-surface mirror (rear-surface, back-silvered). The metal is on the back of the glass. Light crosses the glass, reflects off the metal and crosses the glass again. This is the ordinary household mirror.
Front-surface mirror (first-surface mirror, FSM). The metal is on the face that the light reaches first. The light reflects without entering the glass, which is only a support.
Why a second-surface mirror gives two reflections
In a second-surface mirror the light meets two reflecting boundaries: the bare front face of the glass, then the metal film behind it. The two reflections start from parallel planes separated by the thickness of the glass. The result is two images of the same object: a bright one from the metal and a faint one from the glass face, displaced from each other. The RP Photonics Encyclopedia calls the faint one a ghost image.
How faint the ghost is depends on the angle. For light arriving perpendicular to glass with a refractive index of 1.5, the Fresnel equations give a reflectance of ((1.5 - 1) / (1.5 + 1)) squared, which is 0.04, or 4 percent. Sir David Brewster, in "A Treatise on the Kaleidoscope" (Edinburgh, 1819), quotes Bouguer's older measurements for plate glass: 25 rays reflected out of 1000 at perpendicular incidence, 112 at an angle of incidence of 60 degrees, and 584 at 87 degrees.
What this does inside a kaleidoscope
The light arrives obliquely. The eye looks along the mirrors, not at them, so rays reach the mirrors at shallow angles to the surface, the range where bare glass reflects strongly. Brewster describes the consequence in Chapter III. At small angles of incidence the images from the glass face are faint and interfere little with the brighter images from the metal. As the angle increases, "the one series of images destroys the effect of the other, from their overlapping or imperfect coincidence". He adds that this effect "increases with the thickness of the glass".
The image is made of joints. A kaleidoscope picture is a direct view of the object joined to its reflections along the mirror edges. Brewster states the condition in Chapter II: the image must be reflected from the first surface of the mirror so that direct and reflected image join. With reflection from the rear surface, as in a looking-glass, the two "can never coalesce into one form" and stay separated by the thickness of the mirror glass.
The reflections repeat. A sector on the far side of the field has been reflected several times. In a second-surface mirror each reflection adds its own displaced secondary image and its own gap at the joint. Each reflection also returns less than all of the light, so losses compound. The count of reflections for each layout is covered in two-mirror vs three-mirror kaleidoscopes.
What follows from this with second-surface mirrors:
Ghost lines. A pale duplicate beside sharp edges of the pattern.
Soft seams. A band along each mirror junction where the pattern does not continue cleanly, repeated in every sector.
A blurred centre. In a two-mirror image all sectors meet at one point. With glass in front of the coating, the reflecting planes cannot meet there.
What a front-surface mirror changes
With the metal on the front face there is one reflecting boundary and no second plane to produce a displaced image.
One image per reflection. No ghost from a glass face in front of the metal.
Joints at the reflecting plane. Two front-surface mirrors can be set so that their reflecting faces meet along a line.
Loss per reflection set by the coating alone. The light never reaches the glass.
Brewster reached first-surface reflection by other means. His 1819 reflectors were polished steel or speculum metal (Chapter V), or plate glass, which could have its rear face ground or covered with black wax or varnish to remove its reflective power (Chapter VI). The chemical silvering of glass dates from 1835, after his first edition.
The trade-off: an exposed coating
A second-surface mirror is durable because its metal film sits behind glass. A front-surface mirror gives up that protection. RP Photonics describes it as substantially more sensitive.
Handling. RP Photonics notes that fingerprints can cause oxidation of the metal and that cleaning may not restore full optical quality. Mirrors are held by their edges.
Cleaning. Edmund Optics states that a bare metal coating should never be touched or cleaned with anything but clean, dry air. Loose dust is blown off, not rubbed.
Protective layer. Many front-surface mirrors carry a thin transparent dielectric layer over the metal. Edmund Optics describes it as protecting the aluminium from oxidation and giving an abrasion-resistant surface.
Every mark is multiplied. A scratch or dust particle on a mirror appears in every sector.
For this reason the mirror system of a kaleidoscope sits inside the tube, out of reach of fingers.
How to tell which mirror type an instrument uses
The pencil test - on a loose mirror only. Touch the tip of a pencil lightly to the surface. On a second-surface mirror there is a visible gap between the tip and its reflection, because the film is behind the glass. On a front-surface mirror the tip and its reflection touch. Brewster records the same observation in Chapter III. The test is for a loose mirror, not for an assembled instrument.
On an assembled kaleidoscope the mirrors cannot be touched, so the check is visual. The checklist below lists what to look for, under strong, direct light.
Read the specification. "Front-surface mirror", "first-surface mirror" and "FSM" mean the same thing. If a listing says only "mirror", ask. Other criteria are in what to look for when buying a kaleidoscope.
Checklist
The specification names the mirror type: front-surface, first-surface or FSM.
The centre point of a two-mirror image is sharp.
Pattern lines cross the mirror junctions without a step or a dividing band.
No pale duplicate beside a high-contrast edge in the outer sectors. Some dimming there is normal. A doubled outline is not.
No dust specks or scratches repeated in every sector.
The image was judged under direct, strong light.
FAQ
What is a front-surface mirror?
A front-surface mirror, also called a first-surface mirror, carries its reflective metal coating on the face that the light reaches first. The light reflects without entering the glass, which serves only as a flat support. An ordinary household mirror is the reverse: the coating is on the back of the glass.
What is the difference between a first surface mirror and a regular mirror?
A regular mirror reflects from a metal film behind the glass, so the bare front face of the glass adds a second, weaker reflection displaced from the main one. A first-surface mirror reflects from a film on the front face, giving one reflection and one image, with the coating left exposed.
Why do ordinary mirrors create ghost lines in a kaleidoscope?
Light inside a kaleidoscope meets the mirrors at shallow angles, where bare glass reflects strongly. Brewster's 1819 Treatise cites Bouguer's figures for plate glass: 25 rays in 1000 reflected at perpendicular incidence, 112 at 60 degrees and 584 at 87 degrees. The glass-face image overlaps the image from the metal behind it.
Did Brewster use front-surface mirrors?
Not in the modern sense. In the 1819 Treatise, Brewster required reflection from the first surface and described two routes: polished reflectors of steel or speculum metal, or plate glass whose rear face could be ground or blackened. Chemical silvering of glass dates from 1835, after his first edition.
How can I tell if a mirror is front-surface?
Touch a pencil tip lightly to a loose mirror. If the tip meets its reflection with no gap, the coating is on the front. If a gap is visible, the coating is behind the glass. Brewster recorded this in 1819: an object touching a looking-glass is separated from its image by the glass thickness.
Can the mirrors inside a kaleidoscope be cleaned?
With care only. The coating of a front-surface mirror is exposed, and wiping it can drag dust across the film and scratch it. Edmund Optics states that bare metal coatings should be cleaned only with clean, dry air. For a specific instrument, ask its maker before touching the mirrors.
About Studio Yabaye
I build Studio Yabaye kaleidoscopes and teleidoscopes with front-surface mirror systems in several configurations, with mirrors cut to size for each model, housed in a brass tube, cut, fitted and hand-finished in the studio. The studio is based in Israel and ships worldwide. The current range is at all products, and questions can be sent through the contact page.
Comments